Citroën C5 Hatchback (2004-2008) running costs and reliability

Looking for a different model? (change model)

Running costs rating: 3 out of 53.0

Written by Dan Harrison Published: 6 June 2019

Miles per pound (mpp)

Reliable fuel consumption data for comparison purposes is not available for this model.

What is miles per pound?

Fuel economy

A more stringent standard for fuel economy (WLTP) was introduced from September 2017, and this model was not required to undergo that test. Its fuel economy measured under the previous test system was 28 - 52 mpg. However these figures are less likely to be achievable in real world driving and so should never be compared to another car's mpg which was measured under the newer, more realistic WLTP system.

View mpg & specs for any version

The biggest burden for the new buyer is depreciation – the 2001-2004 C5 performed poorly against rivals – particularly in petrol forms. But as the car gets older, this will become less of an issue. Diesels offer excellent fuel economy and petrols compare well to rivals. Service intervals are well spaced and Citroën dealers generally offer good value for money.

Insurance groups are 8-14.

C5 scores well on the eco front. With an average of 173 g/km CO2 across the range, its emissions are quite low for a medium-sized hatchback. However, it’s worth noting that the line up has a high number of diesel models, bringing the average down and giving buyers more choices of low-emission versions. Diesels typically produce less CO2 than petrol engines with similar power outputs.

Eco-conscious buyers should consider the 1.6-litre diesel, which is one of the greenest models in the range. The range is also fairly economical, averaging 42 mpg.

The 2004 C5 should have had many of the defects that have annoyed owners ironed out. Time will tell. However, there are still too many unexplained creaks and rattles for true peace of mind, and vehicles we have tested have displayed warning messages relating to the car’s electronic systems.