Primary Navigation Mobile

Proton GEN-2 Saloon (2008-2012) review

Looking for a different model? (change model)
Parkers overall rating: 2 out of 52.0

At a glance

Price new £11,030 - £11,840
Used prices £343 - £1,694
Road tax cost £245 - £255
Insurance group 16
Get an insurance quote with
Fuel economy Not tested to latest standards
Range 462 miles
View full specs for a specific version

Available fuel types

Petrol

Alternative fuel

Pros & cons

PROS

Looks more sophisticated than hatchback, cheap to buy used

CONS

Poor interior quality, dull to drive, heavy depreciation, coarse engine

Written by David Ross Published: 6 June 2019

Overview

The Proton GEN-2 Persona four-door saloon looks a little more sophisticated than the five-door hatchback. The enclosed boot also offers extra safety, but it’s a below-par and disappointing effort overall. It does have one ace up its sleeve: buyers on a budget can cut their fuel bills in half with an LPG ecoLogic model, but the main problem is poor value for money overall.

The GEN-2 fails to meet the high expectations demanded by its price tag. The interior isn’t plush enough and – despite Lotus’ helping hand – the GEN-2 Persona isn’t sporty or fun to drive. The Skoda Octavia costs only a little more new and is a hugely superior car in every respect.